Day Twenty: Mobilizing Meaning Otherwise

SDS 237: Data Ethnography

Lindsay Poirier

Final Project Reminders

  • First Draft due on Tuesday
  • User guide demonstrates having completed substantial research across all five project exercises
  • Language, visuals, and formats are tailored towards a particular audience
  • No minimum word count, but example user guide is about 4000 words long

Final Project Scoring

  • Meets Criteria: Clearly communicating the contexts that produced data in a format appropriate for a given audience
  • Exceeds Criteria: Creatively playing with the style and medium of communication in order to better reach and engage an audience

Reading Discussion

Free-writing: Consider a numeric metric you use to measure something about yourself. Pick something that has special meaning for you. Is there a number that you strive for? How do you know when your score is “good”?

Principles for Active Listening

  1. Suspend judgment
  2. Be curious
  3. Halt internal commentary
  4. Listen with intention
  5. Express gratitude for sharing

Structured Story-tellling

  1. Find a partner, and decide who will speak first and who will speak second.
  2. Two minutes:
  • First speaker: Provides uninterrupted narration about this measure. What does it mean to you? How did it come to have its meaning? How do you decide what success looks like?
  • Second speaker: Listens with intention: What does this number mean to this person?
  1. One minute:
  • Second speaker: Reflect back on what you heard/ask questions, etc. (e.g. “From what I understand…”)
  • First speaker: Affirm, correct, clarify, but also listen for what they heard
  1. Swap and repeat.
  • Through what mechanisms did people decide what was good?
  • Did you identify social structures at play in making this number meaningful?
  • Did you hear your partner talk about ways this number might mean different things to different people?

Mobilizing Data Narratives

  • Mobilization refers to the processes by which people prepare something to be put to use or into action
  • Stakeholders strategically engage in meaning-making activities around data
  • Shapes societal interpretations of data

Mobilizing Data Narratives

  • Mobilization refers to the processes by which people prepare something to be put to use or into action
  • Stakeholders strategically engage in meaning-making activities around data
  • Shapes societal interpretations of data

Narrating Data

  • Curating plot details and trajectories
    • Choosing variables to report on
    • Choosing how to sequence statistics
  • Engaging literary or rhetorical devices
    • Techniques of communication designed to evoke a reaction from the listener
  • Identifying the sense-making tools
    • Visuals
    • Statistical terminology (e.g. “statistically significant”)

What story-telling elements bring the data in this ad to life?

What story-telling elements bring the data in this ad to life?

What story-telling elements bring the data in this ad to life?

What story-telling elements bring the data in this ad to life?

“The actual number of Americans jailed or imprisoned, about 2.3 million.” - Matt Korostoff

https://mkorostoff.github.io/incarceration-in-real-numbers/

Revision Expectations

  • Revision = re - vision = seeing again
  • Involves more than spelling and grammar fixes and word changes; editing is only one component of revision
  • Things to consider:
    • Recognize and re-articulate the purpose
    • Refine the focus (audience and presentation)
    • Clarify the argument
    • Strengthen and hone evidence

https://writingcenter.unc.edu/tips-and-tools/revising-drafts/