Day Twelve: Participant Observation

SDS 237: Data Ethnography

Lindsay Poirier

Think about a measurement you took in the past two weeks. How did you engage your body when taking that measurement?

Turn to a neighbor and discuss:

  1. How would you characterize the role and importance of your body in taking that measurement?

Reading Discussion

Cartesian Dualism

  • Western philosophy conceptualizes body as essentially biological
    • Often perceived as closer to nature (further from culture)
  • Rene Descartes: conceptualized mind/body distinct and separate
    • Mind: non-physical or non-material, associated with consciousness, thought, and self-awareness
    • Separate from brain: material human sensory organ

Feminist Critiques of Cartesian Dualism

  • Mind and mental capacity often gets associated with masculinity
  • Physical and natural body often gets associated with femininity
  • Female bodies often perceived as closer to Nature
    • “Mother Earth” vs. Man
    • “virgin water” or “virgin forests”
    • Nature itself is often feminized

Embodiment

  • Around 1980s, feminist scholarship in anthropology, sociology, etc shifted
    • Not just studies of the body,
    • Studies of how experiences living in bodies shape how we move through the world and what we perceive
    • Also study the symbolic meaning we inscribe on bodies
  • Body not just biological but experiences are embodied
  • Critiqued essentialism about bodies - the idea that a set of characteristics define the “essence” of a body
    • No singular characteristics to separate a “normal” body from an abnormal body
    • No singular characteristics to separate a body from machines

Why might feminist scholars call on us to view data practices as embodied?

What is participant observation?

  • An ethnographic method that involves embedding oneself in a community’s day-to-day activities
  • Ethnographer observes how people behave and interact through participation
  • Ethnographer takes written notes on what they observe which are later elaborated

When do ethnographers do participant observation?

  • To figure out what kinds of interview questions to ask
  • To place checks on what people say during interviews
  • To gather details about the physical and social environments in which individuals engage
  • To deepen the ethnographer’s understanding of social contexts

What gets recorded in participant observation?

  • Details about:
    • The physical setting
    • The quantity and demographics of participants
    • Their physical appearance (such as attire)
    • Their traffic
    • The tools they use and/or exchange
    • Their physical movements
    • The way they communicate with one another
    • …and more.

What might be some disadvantages to this method?

Ethical Guidelines

  • When should you announce yourself?
  • Do you need informed consent?
  • When is it advisable to identify participants?
  • How should I behave in the space?

Tips for Taking Field Notes

  • Record the date, time, and place of data collection
  • Record as much detail as you can about what you observe
  • Leave space in notes to expand later
  • Use abbreviations and shorthand when possible
  • Create maps and graphics to help you remember details

Expanding Field Notes

  • Schedule a time to do it shortly after observation
  • Convert your notes into a descriptive narrative
  • Layer interpretations of your observations